MSR Trailshot vs MSR Through-Hyperlink: Water Filter Comparability


Weight, ease of use, packability and worth are the 4 most necessary components I contemplate when choosing a water filter. There are a number of water purification choices out there and I like to decide on the very best one for every journey. For instance, I’ve discovered that high-volume gravity filters are completely great for leisurely backpacking journeys with massive teams, whereas smaller techniques like the favored Sawyer Squeeze are perfect for solo endeavors pushing the miles ahead. This fall, I added two extra filters to my rotation.

I attempted two ultralight filters from MSR: Trailshot and Through-Hyperlink. Whereas they’ve very totally different filtering strategies, they’re each perfect for lengthy path runs, day-hikes or fast-packing journeys. Each filters are glorious the place athletes require small quantities of water and whereas conserving as little weight as potential. Let’s check out their similarities and variations.

situations of evaluate

Over the previous few months, I’ve examined each of those filters on quite a lot of lengthy path runs and hikes. I centered totally on ease of use, pace, packability, and weight in my comparisons. These filters are an ideal alternative for each quick and light-weight solo journey.

MSR Trailshot

at a look

MSR Trailshot vs MSR Through-Hyperlink Comparability: MSR Trailshot.

  • $49.95 MSRP
  • 5 ounces
  • 2.4 x 6 x 6 inches
  • 1 liter/minute movement
  • space washable

Go to MSR Through-Hyperlink At-a-Look.

preliminary impressions

Filtering instantly into my bladder in a notoriously “gross” Wasatch Lake.

“Wow, it’s essential to consider within the filter if you are going to drink out of that.” My first expertise with the MSR Trailshot was on a protracted journey with a bunch of mates. In an effort to maintain up with these pace demons, I traveled as gentle as potential and threw a filter into my pack as a substitute of an additional liter of water. Proper out of the field I discovered the Trailshot to be extraordinarily simple and straightforward to make use of. It reliably filters water instantly into any container, though pumping it requires little bodily effort.

I like how simple it’s to cover the Trailshot when not in use. It suits seamlessly into any backpack pocket, together with hip belt, shoulder or fanny pack pockets. Moreover, it filters both in any container or instantly in your mouth. For trails the place water is ample, hikers can theoretically go with out water and cease by way of trailshot to drink instantly from the supply.

Whereas I really like the simplicity and packability of Trailshot, the filtering course of requires a bit finesse. First, you may must discover a place the place you possibly can sit whereas balancing the filter in a single hand and your water container within the different. It took a bit apply to get the whole lot in place whereas pumping the filter vigorously, however by my second run with the Trailshot it already obtained simpler. General, that is a particularly environment friendly approach to filter water the place the aim is to hold much less water and cease filtering extra usually.

Trailshot professionals and cons

MSR Trailshot vs MSR Thru-Link

Spending extra time actively filtering water additionally means colder arms in winter.

professionals

  • Light-weight and carry anyplace, will slot in fanny pack or hip belt pocket
  • Multifaceted expertise; Simply filters into any container (tender flask, bladder, Nalgene, and so forth.).
  • able to exit of the field

Shortcoming

  • Filtering requires bodily effort
  • Will be tough in shallow/soiled water
  • heavier than through-link

Purchase the MSR Trailshot Filter

at a look

MSR Trailshot vs MSR Through-Hyperlink Comparability: MSR Through-Hyperlink.

  • $39.95
  • 2.5 oz
  • 7.5 x 1.6 x 1.6 inches
  • 1.5 liter/min movement
  • space washable

Soar in at a look on the MSR Trailshot.

preliminary impressions

The through-link filtering course of takes the identical period of time because it takes to refill your bladder. Excellent for quick hikers and path runners.

Through-Hyperlink is a singular in-line filter that attaches on to your hydration bladder. It requires no lively filtering and supplies a gentle stream of unpolluted water with each sip. It is perfect for hikers, runners and fast-packers who already use a hydration bladder and need to filter as little time as potential. Though it could possibly *technically* be used as a gravity filter, you need to repeatedly press the chunk valve for it to work. This makes Through-Hyperlink a much less versatile filter than different choices.

Filters available on the market with comparable weights (such because the Sawyer Micro or Mini) require much more work. Through-Hyperlink FKTs are a viable possibility for effort or longer runs (akin to from rim to rim to rim) the place you need to cease and filter with as little time as potential. All you need to do is fill your bladder, make sure that the filter is related, and maintain trekking.

I did not learn Through-Hyperlink’s directions and put it in my working vest for my first use. If I had gone via the guidelines beforehand, I’d have observed the majority and awkwardness of the filter hooked up to my working waste bladder, and trimmed the straw. Nonetheless, even when I’ve reconfigured, the thru-link is bizarre with smaller packs. Ideally, I would like to make use of it with a trampoline-style suspension (just like the Osprey Daypack).

Through-Hyperlink Professionals and Cons

MSR Trailshot vs MSR Thru-Link

I could not discover a approach to get the filter to put down comfortably with my working vest.

professionals

  • very gentle
  • It takes little or no time to cease to “filter” the water
  • Appropriate with any bladder

Shortcoming

  • Requires a little bit of setup earlier than use
  • Feels heaviness with out the proper pack
  • Each sip requires *skosh* extra effort
  • Much less Versatile Than Trailshot

Purchase MSR Through-Hyperlink Filter

MSR Trailshot vs MSR Through-Hyperlink: Which Ought to I Select and When?

Due to their totally different types, I select Through-Hyperlink for hikes and Trailshot for path runs. I do my greatest to drink on the go whereas working, and the additional effort required to pump the thru-link whereas consuming was simply too laborious for a constant movement whereas working. Additionally, I could not discover a approach to make the Through-Hyperlink lie down comfortably whereas utilizing my strolling vest. A big day-hiking pack has loads of room to stash the filter. Nonetheless, I’ve had a ton of success utilizing Through-Hyperlink on lengthy hikes the place my pace is extra manageable and I do not need to cease for prolonged durations of time for filtering.

The Trailshot is my go-to for top coronary heart price actions, akin to fast-packing, lengthy path runs, or all-day mountain bike rides. Primarily, it’s because I’m able to take brief and frequent breaks and take solely as a lot as I want directly. And, after I’m carried out filtering, I haven’t got to fret about placing in additional effort to pump the filter via the straw.

closing ideas

MSR Trailshot vs MSR Thru-Link

Whichever filter you select, it’ll match completely with lengthy days within the mountains.

There are lots of choices for water purification available in the market. Every has very particular professionals and cons, and it is laborious to determine which one is good for you. MSR’s two ultralight filters, Trailshot and Through-Hyperlink, are great decisions for hikers and athletes who journey quick and light-weight. One liter of water weighs 2.2 kilos. That is why it makes a number of sense to convey a filter that weighs lower than half a pound and continuously carries much less water. With both of those filters and loads of water, I really feel assured carrying lower than a liter of water at a time.

Purchase the MSR Trailshot Filter

Purchase MSR Through-Hyperlink Filter

MSR Trailshot and Through-Hyperlink Filters have been donated for evaluate functions/

Affiliate Disclosure

This web site incorporates affiliate hyperlinks, which implies that Trek could obtain a proportion of any services or products you buy utilizing the hyperlinks in articles or commercials. The customer pays the identical worth they’d in any other case, and your buy helps help Trek’s ongoing aim of offering you with high quality backpacking recommendation and knowledge. Thanks on your help!

To study extra, please go to the About web page of this web site.



Supply hyperlink